Archive
Tag "teaching"

Over at languagelog, Geoffrey Pullum takes a student to task for writing on a test that some phrases in an example sentence “were not deemed noun phrases.”  He feels that students shouldn’t be “deeming” anything, as they’re the students and he’s the professor, and that further pomposity was added by the passive voice.  When I read his post, I realized that if I had been grading that paper, I would have interpreted the student’s locution entirely differently: it’s possible that the student used the passive voice to invoke unnamed experts who have already done the deeming elsewhere, and the student was merely reporting on that fact.  I’m sure it would have struck me that the student was weighing in a bit too heavily to make his point, however it’s not entirely clear to me that it was the student who intended to do the deeming in this case.

Either way, it couldn’t have been a very high-level course, as the task was to identify noun phrases in a sentence, so I think all the deeming on that subject has been done.

Read More

Apparently many NYU students would be willing to sell their votes. Half of the freshman polled in a recent NYU study would sell their right to vote (forever) for one million dollars. Here’s a quote from the article:

“The part that I find amazing is that so many folks think one vote can make a difference,” Dalton Conley, sociology department chairman, said.

The part I find amazing is that a department chair would go on record saying this.

(via kottke)

Read More

Every semester I teach at Rutgers I try to get a “smart classroom” which means a classroom with a built-in beamer so that I can hook up my laptop and lecture with my slides. Rooms have already been assigned for Spring08, and it turns out that both of the courses I’ll be teaching are in rooms described as having “overhead projectors” in them. Great, I thought (non-sarcastically), I don’t have to plead to have the rooms switched! You see I had been thinking of the beamers the way they are set up at the GC, which is to say, suspended from the ceiling (this often makes for fun times when students have to stand on tables to press buttons when professors can’t figure out the remotes, but that’s another story). Sadly, however, this is not what is meant by an overhead projector. An overhead projector is that old-school box with a lamp and a fan and some mirrors and lenses that shines your transparencies (or your scroll of acetate, if you’re that kind of overhead projector user) first up and then out onto a screen. Why “overhead”? Nothing about the whole procedure is overhead — the box, the lenses, the mirrors, the projected image, nothing really ends up over your head, if you’re standing up. And as far as I know this is not a case of a description becoming a name and subsequently failing to describe when the object it denotes changes (see Dart, river, mouth of). So I went to the wikipedia article on overhead projectors, which, although failing to illuminate me on the origin of the name, did point me to both the overhead-projector-based art project The Art of the Overhead (check out their sweet interface!) and this video, which shows you how to make your own beamer out of an overhead projector and an lcd monitor. Make it so!

Read More

A clarification on the post below: I wouldn’t actually sabotage wikipedia; it’s easy enough to figure out when students have plagiarized without resorting to tampering with what is an excellent free resource. That said, it seems that quoting from wikipedia in an academic context is not really a good idea, regardless of whether the instructor has been nefarious. The New York Times reports that a history department has banned citing wikipedia as a research source. Why do they use wikipedia so often? I realize it’s free, online, and easy to access. However for most college students this is also true of many (potentially more vetted) online resources, including many encyclopedias, made available by their academic institutions. As long as wikipedia remains the lazy student’s plagiarism source, it will continue to be easy for instructors to spot the lazy students.

Read More

In a meeting today of Linguistics 101 teachers at Rutgers we were discussing plagiarism.  A colleague made a hilarious suggestion: give students a homework question about topic x, then go to the wikipedia article on topic x and alter it to be incorrect.  Laugh at the results.  I expanded on the theme, positing that one could insert a random word, say, donut, into the entry on topic x and expect to see donut on at least one submitted homework. I might actually try this.

Read More

In a lecture the other day, I had a slide on “neologisms” to illustrate the concept of productivity. This was in Linguistics 101, a course populated by undergraduates from a wide variety of majors, and I thought I’d use “weblog” as an example of a neologism. So I pointed to “weblog” on the slide and asked what the word meant. Silence. This is a tough class to crack as it’s in the evening and they’re tuckered out and digesting, so I often have to resort to calling on individual students. No worry, I thought, as it’s an easy question for someone to answer, and it’s just their general disinclination to speak in class that’s causing the blank stares. I choose a name from the list. The student in question looks up at me with the same blank stare. “Umm, do you mean ‘blog’?” she asks, and then provides the definition.

It is actually the case that ‘weblog’ has ceased to function as a denoting term amongst this age group, having been supplanted by the catchier ‘blog’, thereby obscuring the etymology.

I felt just a tiny bit old after that class.

Read More